Our verdict
AthenaHQPeec AI
- AthenaHQ Starter costs $295 per month, includes 3,600 tracking credits and lists 11 engines, while Peec AI Starter costs $95 for 50 prompts across three selected models.[4]
- Under a 30-day, three-engine example, AthenaHQ Starter provides 40 daily-equivalent prompts and Peec AI Starter provides 50, or 4,500 monthly answers.[6]
- AthenaHQ documents the deeper native content workflow, including brief approval, article generation, revision and CMS publishing.[2]
- Peec AI offers lower published monitoring costs, MCP on every brand plan and customer API access from Pro upward.[8]
- Choose AthenaHQ for integrated content production and broader listed Starter coverage; choose Peec AI for lower-cost daily tracking and clearer prompt-based budgeting.[7]
Full comparison
Measure
Act
Connect
Team
What is AI visibility monitoring?
AI visibility monitoring measures how often an AI search system mentions a brand, recommends it, or cites its website in response to tracked prompts. It can also show competitors, cited sources, sentiment and changes over time.[1][2]
Also worth a look: Neither AthenaHQ nor Peec AI is shown in this comparison with revenue attribution or AI crawler analytics from server logs or CDNs. Finseo covers both, with survey-based attribution matched to orders and bot analytics from its Business plan at €175 per month billed yearly (€210 monthly), excl. VAT. Finseo is built by the team behind this site.
For content and SEO teams, the useful question is not simply whether a platform reports a visibility score. It is whether the tool connects that evidence to the work that follows: choosing topics, improving pages, assigning actions, creating content and measuring results.
AthenaHQ and Peec AI take different approaches. AthenaHQ’s Starter plan combines a credit-based response allowance with 11 listed engines and a native content workflow.[3][4] Peec AI sells prompt-based daily tracking, with three selected models on its self-service plans, published monthly answer totals and separate agent credits.[4]
The practical choice is therefore between AthenaHQ’s more production-oriented workspace and Peec AI’s lower-priced, easier-to-normalise monitoring tiers.
AthenaHQ vs Peec AI at a glance
| Criterion | AthenaHQ | Peec AI |
|---|---|---|
| Entry paid price | Starter: $295/month[3] | Starter: $95/month[3] |
| Pricing unit | Credits; one credit equals one AI response[3][5] | Prompt allocation multiplied by selected models and daily tracking; Starter publishes 4,500 monthly answers[6] |
| Engines on entry paid plan | Starter lists 11 engines, including ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, Gemini, Claude, Copilot, Grok, DeepSeek, Meta AI and Mistral[3] | Three chosen models on each self-service plan; the broader catalogue includes ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overview, AI Mode, Gemini, Naver AI Briefing, ERNIE and Bing AI Mode[5][7] |
| Seats | Unlimited users on Starter[3] | Unlimited users on every brand plan[3] |
| Content features | Brief creation and approval, article generation, revision, CMS publishing, scheduling and version history[2] | Prioritized Actions, evidence-backed briefs, action drafting and an agent for analysis and content briefs[4][2] |
| API | Paid add-on on Starter; included in Enterprise[3] | Excluded from Starter; included from Pro upward[7] |
| MCP | Official MCP server; exact plan entitlement is not clearly published[8] | Included on every brand plan[4] |
| Agency or pitch workspaces | Unlimited seats, but a self-service project cap is not published in the cited pricing material[5] | Separate agency plans with shared allocations and limits of 3, 10, 25 or unlimited live client accounts[5] |
Checked against the vendors’ published pricing and product documentation on 15 November 2026.
How the comparison works
The comparison uses five criteria relevant to a three-person content or SEO team:
- Monitoring economics: how the published price translates into monthly AI responses under a common assumption.[4]
- Engine coverage: whether a plan monitors a broad fixed set or a smaller number of selected models.[9][10]
- Actionability: whether evidence leads to recommendations, briefs, articles, revisions or publishing.[2]
- Integration access: whether API and MCP are included at the entry or mid-tier level.[7]
- Team and agency fit: seats, projects, client accounts and shared allocation rules.[5]
Prices use monthly billing unless stated otherwise. Three users are assumed because both vendors publish unlimited users or seats on the relevant plans, so no extra seat charge is required for a three-person team.[3][7]
The calculations below use 30 days, three engines, one run per prompt-engine pair per day and one location. This is a comparison assumption, not a claim about AthenaHQ’s default refresh schedule.[11][6]
What does AthenaHQ offer?
Overview
AthenaHQ’s paid entry point is the Starter plan at $295 per month. It includes 3,600 tracking credits, with one credit defined as one AI response, and lists 11 engines.[3]
The Starter plan also includes unlimited topics, prompts and competitors, country-level support, integrations, CSV export, on-page and off-page actions, a content optimisation agent and self-learning content improvement.[3] The unlimited-prompt wording does not remove the 3,600-credit allowance: every generated AI response still consumes the published response budget.[4]
AthenaHQ’s Essential plan is free and lists 300 credits plus five engines, but its documentation does not publish whether those credits renew, expire or require a payment card.[8][2] For a budgetable comparison, Starter is the clearer plan because its 3,600-credit allowance is explicitly monthly.[4]
Key features
- Eleven listed Starter engines include ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, Gemini, Claude, Microsoft Copilot, Grok, DeepSeek, Meta AI and Mistral.[6]
- AthenaHQ analyses prompts and responses, sources and competitors, and provides content recommendations.[10][4]
- Its content workspace lets an editor select topics, generate a brief, review the brief and approve full-article generation.[2]
- Editors can revise generated content, accept or reject highlighted changes, publish through a connected CMS, schedule publication and review version history.[2]
- Content modes include Write, Optimise, Snipe, Slice and a blank editor, with Word, PDF and HTML export.[2]
- Starter includes on-page and off-page actions and a content optimisation agent.[3]
- The Content API consumes content credits, but a fixed monthly article allowance or per-article credit price is not published in the cited documentation.[4]
Strengths
- AthenaHQ provides broader simultaneous engine coverage on Starter than Peec AI’s self-service plans.[12]
- Its documented workflow extends from brief approval to article generation, revision and CMS publishing.[2]
- The platform combines monitoring with recommendations and actions instead of limiting the product to a reporting dashboard.[7][2]
- Unlimited users cover a three-person internal team without an additional seat charge.[12][7]
Limitations
- Starter costs $295 per month before the API add-on, making it more expensive than Peec AI’s Starter and Pro plans on published subscription price.[4]
- The 3,600-credit allowance equals fewer three-engine daily-equivalent prompts than Peec Starter’s published allocation.[4]
- The exact number of articles that the included content credits fund is not published.[2]
- AthenaHQ’s MCP documentation describes an official server but does not clearly publish entitlement by plan.[8][13]
- The relationship between the Starter card’s “$300/month free credit” wording and its 3,600-credit allowance is not published.[4][3]
Pricing checked 15 November 2026
AthenaHQ Starter costs $295 per month and includes 3,600 tracking credits.[3] Enterprise pricing and allocation are custom, while Essential is free with 300 listed credits whose renewal terms are not published.[3]
The annual pricing toggle advertises a 17% discount, but exact annual checkout prices and public API or extra-credit rates are not published in the cited material.[8]
Verdict: Best for a content team that wants the visibility platform and editorial production workflow in the same workspace, especially when 11-engine Starter coverage matters more than the lowest monitoring cost.[8]
What does Peec AI offer?
Overview
Peec AI’s self-service brand plans begin at $95 per month for Starter, followed by Pro at $245 and Advanced at $495.[6] Each plan lets a customer choose three models and includes daily tracking.[4]
The plans publish prompt allocations of 50, 150 and 350 respectively, alongside 4,500, 13,500 and 31,500 monthly AI answers.[6] Those figures correspond to the prompt allocation multiplied by three active models and 30 days of daily tracking.[5]
Peec’s model choice is narrower at any one time than AthenaHQ Starter’s listed 11-engine coverage, although customers can add models for a published tier-specific fee.[7][9]
Key features
- Starter includes 50 tracked prompts, three active models, one project, unlimited users, 500 agent credits and MCP.[7]
- Pro includes 150 tracked prompts, three active models, two projects, 750 agent credits and customer API access.[7]
- Advanced includes 350 tracked prompts, three active models, five projects, 1,000 agent credits and customer API access.[7]
- Peec AI reports visibility, sentiment, retrieved sources, inline citations, citation share and source visibility.[14][6]
- Its Actions system ranks recommendations by impact and provides evidence, suggested structures and workflow states.[1]
- The agent produces charts, to-do lists and content briefs; agent consumption varies by task complexity and quality settings.[4]
- MCP is included on every brand plan, while customer API access begins at Pro.[4][8]
- Peec documents UI scraping for data collection and says it runs prompts daily; underlying platform model and search behaviour can vary.[15]
Strengths
- Peec Starter has the lowest entry price in this comparison at $95 per month.[6]
- Its published monthly answer totals make monitoring capacity easier to budget.[4]
- Peec Pro costs $245 per month and includes the customer API, while AthenaHQ Starter costs $295 before its paid API add-on.[4][8]
- MCP is included on every Peec brand plan.[4]
- Unlimited users cover a three-person team without an additional seat charge.[7][16]
- Actions, briefs and agent features give content teams a route from visibility evidence to assigned work.[8][4]
Limitations
- Self-service plans activate three selected models rather than AthenaHQ Starter’s 11 listed engines.[12]
- The three-model allowance means that broader engine coverage requires model add-ons or a higher commercial arrangement.[12]
- Peec’s documented Actions workflow does not establish the same integrated full-article editor and CMS publishing sequence documented by AthenaHQ.[2]
- Agent credits are separate from tracking answers, and 500 credits do not represent 500 identical tasks because consumption varies by task complexity and quality settings.[4]
- UI scraping and platform-controlled model selection mean that a selected consumer AI experience does not necessarily pin a model version or retrieval behaviour.[15]
Pricing checked 15 November 2026
Peec AI Starter costs $95 per month for 50 prompts across three selected models and publishes 4,500 monthly answers.[6] Pro costs $245 for 150 prompts and 13,500 monthly answers; Advanced costs $495 for 350 prompts and 31,500 monthly answers.[6]
Annual billing advertises a 15% discount. Additional models cost $30 per month on Starter, $70 on Pro and $140 on Advanced.[7]
Verdict: Best for a content or SEO team that wants clearly published daily monitoring tiers, lower entry cost, included MCP and API access from Pro, while keeping article production in a separate editorial stack.[8][4]
How many monthly answers does each plan provide?
The following is a worked example using only published plan limits and the stated comparison assumptions.
- Set the assumptions: 30 days, three engines, one response per prompt-engine pair per day.
- Calculate the monthly requirement: monthly responses = prompts × engines × runs per day × days.
- AthenaHQ Starter: 3,600 credits ÷ 3 engines ÷ 30 days = 40 three-engine daily-equivalent prompts.[12][3]
- Peec AI Starter: 50 prompts × 3 models × 30 days = 4,500 monthly answers, matching the published total.[6][8]
- Peec AI Pro: 150 prompts × 3 models × 30 days = 13,500 monthly answers.[6]
- Peec AI Advanced: 350 prompts × 3 models × 30 days = 31,500 monthly answers.[6]
| Plan | Monthly price | Published or calculated response allocation | Three-engine daily-equivalent prompts | Cost per 1,000 responses |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AthenaHQ Starter | $295 | 3,600 credits[3] | 40 | $81.94 |
| Peec AI Starter | $95[7] | 4,500 answers[6] | 50 | $21.11 |
| Peec AI Pro | $245[7] | 13,500 answers[6] | 150 | $18.15 |
| Peec AI Advanced | $495[7] | 31,500 answers[6] | 350 | $15.71 |
These are illustrative calculations, not accuracy or value ratings. They exclude add-ons and assign no monetary value to content production, agent work, integrations or support.[2]
A 50-prompt panel across three engines for 30 daily runs requires 4,500 responses. That fits Peec Starter’s published allowance but exceeds AthenaHQ Starter’s 3,600 credits by 900 responses; the price of additional AthenaHQ credits is not published.[4]
Running all 11 AthenaHQ Starter engines against 10 prompts daily would require 3,300 credits, leaving 300 under the same 30-day assumption. Eleven prompts daily across all 11 engines would require 3,630 credits, slightly exceeding the allowance.[4]
Credit systems versus prompt quotas
How should a buyer interpret credits and prompts?
A credit is an execution or response allowance. AthenaHQ defines one credit as one AI response, so the required budget changes with prompt count, engine count, location and cadence.[12][8]
A prompt quota describes the tracked question set, but the total answer volume depends on how many models run that set and how frequently. Peec makes this relationship explicit by publishing both prompt allocations and monthly answer totals.[4]
Agent credits are a separate unit from monitoring answers. Peec states that agent consumption varies with task complexity and quality settings, so agent credits should not be treated as interchangeable with tracked AI answers.[4]
How do sentiment and citation reports compare?
Both platforms report more than simple mention counts, but the published terminology is not identical.
AthenaHQ documents prompt and response analysis, sources, competitors and sentiment monitoring. Its cited material does not publish a numerical sentiment scale in the same detail as Peec’s documentation.[17][2] AthenaHQ’s glossary defines a source as a unique referenced URL and a citation as an occurrence of that source in a response.[13]
Peec AI publishes a 0–100 sentiment scale based on language and context around brand mentions.[14] It distinguishes brand visibility from source visibility and reports retrieved sources, inline citations and citation share.[2][14]
That distinction matters for content teams. A page can support an answer without the brand being named, while a brand mention does not necessarily mean the brand’s website was used.[8][14] A comparison should therefore inspect both brand visibility and source or citation visibility, rather than treating them as equivalent.
Neither vendor’s score should be treated as a permanent ranking. An academic study found that decision polarity changed for up to 27% of queries within five minutes and 28% over 24 hours; those results concern generative-search instability, not AthenaHQ or Peec AI accuracy.[12]
Which content workflow is deeper?
AthenaHQ publishes the more complete native production sequence. An editor can choose a topic, generate and approve a brief, create a full article, revise it, publish through a connected CMS, schedule publication and review version history.[2]
Peec AI’s workflow is evidence-led rather than article-editor-led. Actions rank recommendations by impact, show competitor evidence, provide suggested content structures and move through states such as New, Planned, In progress and Done.[1] The agent can draft action details and produce content briefs, while changes to account data require approval.[4]
This creates a clear division:
- Choose AthenaHQ when content production should happen inside the AI visibility platform.[2]
- Choose Peec AI when the platform should identify and prioritise work for an existing editorial or project-management system.[4][12]
- Do not assume that either workflow guarantees higher traffic, citations or conversions; the cited documentation does not establish such an outcome.[2]
As a further option, Finseo documents per-engine mention and citation visibility plus evidence-backed optimisation tasks that can be exported into other tools.[18]
What do API, MCP and agency features mean for teams?
AthenaHQ’s Starter API is a paid add-on, while Enterprise includes API access.[3] AthenaHQ also documents an official MCP server that can connect assistants such as ChatGPT and Claude to its data, but the cited documentation does not provide a clear per-plan entitlement.[8]
Peec AI excludes customer API access from Starter and includes it from Pro upward.[7] MCP is included on every brand plan.[4] This makes Peec Pro’s integration position straightforward: it costs $245 monthly with API and MCP included, compared with AthenaHQ Starter at $295 before its API add-on.[4][7]
For agencies, Peec publishes separate plans rather than requiring buyers to multiply a brand subscription. Agency Essential costs $245 per month for 10,000 shared tracking credits and three live client accounts; Growth costs $495 for 25,000 credits and 10 accounts; Scale costs $795 for 65,000 credits and 25 accounts; Comprehensive is custom with unlimited allocation and accounts.[5]
Peec defines an agency credit as one prompt, one model and one day, with the allocation shared across projects.[5] AthenaHQ publishes unlimited users and role-based access, but the cited self-service pricing page does not publish a comparable project cap for Starter.[6]
Which tool should a content team choose?
- Choose AthenaHQ Starter if the team needs 11 listed engines and a documented brief-to-article-to-CMS workflow.[12]
- Choose Peec AI Starter if the priority is the lowest-cost published daily monitoring tier with 50 prompts across three models.[8][4]
- Choose Peec AI Pro if the team needs customer API access without moving to an enterprise contract.[8]
- Choose Peec AI Advanced if five projects and 350 tracked prompts are more useful than AthenaHQ’s broader listed Starter engine coverage.[7]
- Choose a separate agency comparison if multiple clients, shared credits or pitch workspaces matter; Peec publishes dedicated agency plans with explicit client-account limits.[5][8]
- Choose neither on price alone if the measurement design is not settled, because more prompts, engines and repeated runs consume different parts of the monitoring budget.[12]
For a three-person team buying monitoring first, Peec AI has the lower published response-normalised cost in this comparison.[8] For a team buying an integrated content-production environment, AthenaHQ documents the more complete native article workflow.[19]
Frequently asked questions
Is AthenaHQ cheaper than Peec AI?
No, AthenaHQ Starter is published at $295 per month, while Peec AI Starter costs $95 and Pro costs $245 per month.[8] AthenaHQ’s justification is broader listed Starter engine coverage and a native content workflow, not a lower monitoring cost per published response.[12]
How many prompts does AthenaHQ Starter include?
AthenaHQ Starter lists unlimited prompts but also includes 3,600 monthly tracking credits, with one credit defined as one AI response.[3][4] Under a 30-day, three-engine, daily-tracking example, that equals 40 three-engine daily-equivalent prompts.[12]
How many answers does Peec AI Starter provide?
Peec AI Starter publishes 50 tracked prompts across three selected models and 4,500 monthly AI answers.[6][4] The answer total corresponds to 50 prompts × three models × 30 days of daily tracking.[5][9]
Does Peec AI have content tools?
Yes. Peec AI documents prioritised Actions, competitor evidence, suggested content structures, action drafting and an agent that can produce content briefs.[1][4] The cited documentation does not describe the same integrated full-article editing and CMS-publishing sequence documented for AthenaHQ.[1][2]
Does AthenaHQ include an API and MCP?
AthenaHQ Starter’s API is a paid add-on, while Enterprise includes API access.[3] AthenaHQ documents an official MCP server, but its cited documentation does not clearly state which plan includes it.[8]
Which is better for an agency?
Peec AI provides a separate agency schedule with shared tracking allocations and explicit live client-account limits, ranging from three on Agency Essential to unlimited on Comprehensive.[5] AthenaHQ publishes unlimited users and role-based access, but the cited self-service pricing material does not publish an equivalent Starter project limit.[6]
Sources
- [1]Actionsdocs.peec.ai ↗
- [2]Contentdocs.athenahq.ai ↗
- [3]Plans & Pricing | Action on AI Searchathenahq.ai ↗
- [4]Agentdocs.peec.ai ↗
- [5]Peec AI Agency Pricing: Plans Built for Multi-Brand Trackingpeec.ai ↗
- [6]Pricing for Peec AI - AI Search Platform for Marketing teams and SEO agenciespeec.ai ↗
- [7]Pricing for Peec AI - AI Search Platform for Marketing teams and SEO agenciespeec.ai ↗
- [8]MCP Serverdocs.athenahq.ai ↗
- [9]A statistical framework for evaluating the repeatability and reproducibility of large language models - PMCpmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov ↗
- [10]Quantifying Uncertainty in AI Visibility: A Statistical Framework for Generative Search Measurementarxiv.org ↗
- [11]Integrations - AthenaHQdocs.athenahq.ai ↗
- [12]Characterizing Web Search in the Age of Generative AIaclanthology.org ↗
- [13]Glossarydocs.athenahq.ai ↗
- [14]Metrics Overviewdocs.peec.ai ↗
- [15]Welcome to Peec AIdocs.peec.ai ↗
- [16]API & Embed Settingsdocs.athenahq.ai ↗
- [17]Understanding your metrics - Peec.ai Docsdocs.peec.ai ↗
- [18]Finseo - AI Visibility Tool for ChatGPT, Claude & Perplexityfinseo.ai ↗
- [19]Platform | Monitor, Understand & Act on AI Search | Action on AI Searchathenahq.ai ↗

